Sesame Street temporary tattoos, $15, with all their favorite little guys. (Look at Mr. Snuffleupagus!)
Ferry boat with two cars, $20. Cue the bathtime adventures!
Play-Doh in 36 colors, enough to make all the things. $12.
The Polar Express 30th Anniversary Edition, $10. Such a magical story.
Kid’s apron, $49, for both real and pretend cooking.
Perfection game, $24, because they shriek with laughter when the timer goes off (and it’s secretly fun for grown-ups, too).
Jelly beans with disgusting flavors, like moldy cheese, canned dog food and stinky socks, to make their little heads explode. $4.
Walkie talkies, $14.50, for top-secret spy missions.
The sweetest shirt for your little bears, $26.
Road tape to turn the whole house into a race track. $13.
Animal slippers to keep their teeny feet warm. $38.
A print for their bedroom wall, $20. Because they really are terrific.