Caboodle for all their coins, lip balm, rubber bands and stickers. (I brought one home from work the other day and my boys LOST THEIR MINDS.)
Bug bingo, for heart-pounding fun.
Pearl wishing bracelet Leave it on until it falls off and your wish will come true.
The softest sweater, in their favorite color. (I love this whole store.)
Too Many Monkeys, a game that’s fast and fun for kids and adults (no but for real).
Astronaut ice cream sandwich, a childhood tradition.
A flip sequins shirt, because they’re just cool.
A plant Toby got one this year and he adores it. He keeps it in his bedroom, waters it every Sunday and named it Jackson.
A wallet, to feel grown-up but still be decidedly little.